I was researching Vonage several months ago, but for various reasons decided against it at that time.
One issue was that TestYourVoIP results were borderline - 3.1 MOS score, with packet discards being the main problem.
I see that a new test is available, and my MOS scores are 3.9 or 4.0 with slightly high jitter (around 9.7 ms) measured sometimes, but not all the times.
I don't see any information about "packet discards" in the new test, which was flagged as a problem in the old one.
Two questions:
1. Could somebody clarify this for me, and help me determine which is going to be a more reliable predictor of sound quality should I go with Voip?
2. Is there anything here specific to Vonage, or would these results apply to any other Voip service?
I was researching Vonage several months ago, but for various reasons decided against it at that time.
One issue was that TestYourVoIP results were borderline - 3.1 MOS score, with packet discards being the main problem.
I see that a new test is available, and my MOS scores are 3.9 or 4.0 with slightly high jitter (around 9.7 ms) measured sometimes, but not all the times.
I don't see any information about "packet discards" in the new test, which was flagged as a problem in the old one.
Two questions:
1. Could somebody clarify this for me, and help me determine which is going to be a more reliable predictor of sound quality should I go with Voip?
2. Is there anything here specific to Vonage, or would these results apply to any other Voip service?
Thanks.
It is hard to comment on another test without knowing the product at the code level however the Vonage Forum test is configured to match the Vonage packet/rate specifications, discards should be reported however. If you can let me know your test id number (reported on the speed page) I will review the detail TCP audit report produced for every test and get back to you. This won't be until tomorrow as I am travelling to London this evening.
It is hard to comment on another test without knowing the product at the code level however the Vonage Forum test is configured to match the Vonage packet/rate specifications, discards should be reported however. If you can let me know your test id number (reported on the speed page) I will review the detail TCP audit report produced for every test and get back to you. This won't be until tomorrow as I am travelling to London this evening.
Thanks.
I'll need to post tomorrow, as it won't let me do another test today, saying I had reached my maximum.
Julianp, the test does specify discards, but it doesn't specify in which direction. Loss on the other hand is specified separately for each direction. How should we interpret the discard result?
DLCphoto, I for one would be interested in a comparison test between the forum test and testyourvoip, taken as close together as possible. It's possible that your service has improved and that the two tests will now agree. My own results are comparable (now that I've installed the latest Java).
DLCphoto, I for one would be interested in a comparison test between the forum test and testyourvoip, taken as close together as possible. It's possible that your service has improved and that the two tests will now agree. My own results are comparable (now that I've installed the latest Java).
I didn't make this clear in my original post, but I did go back to the TestYourVoIP site today, to retest and see if anything had changed. It was the same as several months ago, with a 3.1 to 3.4 MOS score, attributable mostly to packet discards (3.2%). These are on the outgoing path from my computer (to Boston). I get a 4.4 on the path from Boston to me.
OK - the Vonage Test let me repeat it. Results are a bit different from earlier today. Here is what I just found now (a few minutes after repeating the TestYourVoIP test at 3.4).
Test Result # 5031
4.9ms Average Jitter 0.0% Packet Loss 0.0% Packet Discards (I now see where that is presented) Download 2,104,264 bps (was around 4.5 mbps earlier, which is where I usually run) Upload 445,024 bps QOS 59% (was around 97% earlier) RTT 72 ms MaxPause 111 ms MOS Score 4.0
The two tests definitely differ with respect to Packet Discards on my system, with my connection. TestYourVoIP consistently gives me 3 to 7% on the outgoing side, while the VonageForum Test doesn't detect any, apparently.
I just did another repeat test (#5034). More representative download speed and QOS (4.7 mbps and 99%). Still 0.0% Packet Discards. Details here:
Speed test statistics --------------------- Download speed: 4682728 bps Upload speed: 445024 bps Quality of service: 99 % Download test type: socket Upload test type: socket Maximum download pause: 61 ms Average download pause: 5 ms Minimum round trip time to server: 63 ms Average round trip time to server: 71 ms
Voip test statistics -------------------- Jitter: you --> server: 4.5 ms Jitter: server --> you: 9.4 ms Packet loss: you --> server: 0.1 % Packet loss: server --> you: 0.0 % Packet discards: 0.0 % Packets out of order: 0.0 % Number of supported Voip lines: 5 Estimated MOS score: 3.9
Appreciate any clarification here, when you have time to look.
Download 5,005,088 bps Upload 2,247,560 bps QOS 91% RTT 2 ms MaxPause 56 ms
29 simul high quality lines
Download speed: 5148128 bps Upload speed: 2170808 bps Quality of service: 99 % Download test type: socket Upload test type: socket Maximum download pause: 13 ms Average download pause: 2 ms Minimum round trip time to server: 1 ms Average round trip time to server: 1 ms
note... my previous DSL wouldnt have come close to this... my current Cox Cable was not like this until i added a bi-directional amp to it.
dconnor Site Admin
Joined: Mar 05, 2003 Posts: 2264
Location: The Beach
Sounds interesting. Can you provide details? A link?
_________________ Have Questions? Need to speak to Vonage before signing up? Call: 1-888-692-8074 Both Business and Residential customers can call and speak to a Vonage Sales Rep 24 hours a day.
I am a new member to the forums, and a consistently frustrated Vonage customer due to nearly constant choppy connections both ways. I am trying to fix it rather than pay the disconnect fee and leave, but for some reason the speedtest cannot test my Voip. I have PingPlotter running as we speak, but I'm stuck on the Speedtest. I get an error stating "Error: Cannot perform voice-over-IP simulation" Any ideas on why this might not be working on my system? Let me know what info you need from me, other than:
Atlanta GA Comcast cable Modem: Scientific Atlanta DPX2100 Vonage - Linksys WRTP54G Modem --> Vonage --> PC Download: 6.32 Mbps Upload: 369 kbps
Speedtest details:
Speed test statistics --------------------- Download speed: 6324080 bps Upload speed: 369536 bps Quality of service: 97 % Download test type: socket Upload test type: socket Maximum download pause: 166 ms Average download pause: 3 ms Minimum round trip time to server: 26 ms Average round trip time to server: 92 ms
Voip test statistics -------------------- Jitter: you --> server: - ms Jitter: server --> you: - ms Packet loss: you --> server: - % Packet loss: server --> you: 0.0 % Packet discards: 0.0 % Packets out of order: 100.0 % Number of supported Voip lines: 4 Estimated MOS score: --
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
All times are GMT - 5 Hours
Vonage Service Plans
Vonage VoIP Members
Members New patsykf3 New Today 0 Yesterday 0 Total 101029 Who Is On Site Visitors 1 Members 0 Total 1
†AK and HI residents pay $29.95 shipping.
††Limited time offer. Valid for residents of the United States (&DC), 18 years or older, who open new accounts. Offer good while supplies last and only on new account activations. One kit per account/household. Offer cannot be combined with any other discounts, promotions or plans and is not applicable to past purchases. Good while supplies last. Allow up to 2 weeks for shipping. Other restrictions may apply.
1Unlimited calling and other services for all residential plans are based on normal residential, personal, non-commercial use. A combination of factors is used to determine abnormal use, including but not limited to: the number of unique numbers called, calls forwarded, minutes used and other factors. Subject to our Reasonable Use Policy and Terms of Service.
2Shipping and activation fees waived with 1-year agreement. An Early Termination Fee (with periodic pro-rated reductions) applies if service is terminated before the end of the first 12 months. Additional restrictions may apply. See Terms of Service for details.
HIGH SPEED INTERNET REQUIRED. †VALID FOR NEW LINES ONLY. RATES EXCLUDE INTERNET SERVICE, SURCHARGES, FEES AND TAXES. DEVICE MAY BE REFURBISHED. If you subscribe to plans with monthly minutes allotments, all call minutes placed from both from your home and registered ExtensionsTM phones will count toward your monthly minutes allotment. ExtensionsTM calls made from mobiles use airtime and may incur surcharges, depending on your mobile plan. Alarms, TTY and other systems may not be compatible. Vonage 911 service operates differently than traditional 911. See www.vonage.com/911 for details.
Thinking of signing up for Vonage but have questions? Business and Residential customers can call Toll Free 24 hours a day at: 1-888-692-8074 No Vonage Promotion Code or Coupon Codes are required at www.vonage.com to receive any special, best Vonage cheap deals, free sign up offers or discounts.
The Vonage Forum provides the Vonage sign up Best Offer Promotion Deal. If you are considering signing up for Vonage and have found our Vonage
News, Customer Reviews, Forums & all other parts of this site useful, please
use our Vonage Sign up page.
Vonage VoIP Phone Service is redefining communications by offering consumers & small business VoIP Internet phones, an affordable alternative to traditional phone service.
The Vonage VoIP Forum Generated This Page In: 0.25 Seconds and Pages In The Last 60 Seconds The Vonage VoIP Forum
Members
New 
New Today 0
Yesterday 0
Total 101029
Who Is On Site
Visitors 1
Members 0
Total 1
